Export control in the Russian Federation
Export control is a national system of foreign-trade regulation aimed at the non-proliferation of weapons of mass destruction (WMD) and their means of delivery. It restricts the import/export of goods and technologies that may be used for both peaceful and military purposes (dual-use goods). Unlike the EAEU non-tariff regulation (an economic measure), export control is a national system of the Russian Federation based on international non-proliferation commitments.
Legal basis
- Federal Law No. 183-FZ of 18.07.1999 "On Export Control" — the principal law (subject matter, principles, methods, authorities);
- Federal Law No. 73-FZ of 26.03.2022 — transferred the authority to approve the control lists from the President to the Government of the Russian Federation;
- control lists (6 lists) — approved by resolutions of the Government of the Russian Federation of 16.07.2022 and 19.07.2022;
- liability: Article 14.20 of the Code of Administrative Offences (KoAP) (breach of export-control legislation), Article 189 of the Criminal Code (illegal export/transfer of dual-use technologies), Article 226.1 of the Criminal Code (smuggling of dual-use goods).
The international basis is formed by multilateral export-control regimes in which Russia participates:
- Wassenaar Arrangement — conventional arms, dual-use goods and technologies;
- Nuclear Suppliers Group (NSG) — nuclear materials and equipment;
- Missile Technology Control Regime (MTCR) — missile technologies;
- Australia Group — chemical and biological weapons.
Control lists (6 lists)
Control lists are lists of goods, technologies and information subject to export control. Until 2022 they were approved by decrees of the President of the Russian Federation; after the amendments (Federal Law No. 73-FZ of 26.03.2022) they were re-approved by resolutions of the Government. A good falling within any of the lists requires a permissive document.
| List | Scope | Current act | Former presidential decree |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Nuclear materials | nuclear materials, equipment, special non-nuclear materials and technologies (NSG trigger list) | RF Government Resolution No. 1285 of 16.07.2022 | Decree No. 202 of 14.02.1996 |
| 2. Dual-use (nuclear purposes) | dual-use equipment and materials and related technologies applied for nuclear purposes | RF Government Resolution No. 1286 of 16.07.2022 | Decree No. 36 of 14.01.2003 |
| 3. Missile weapons | equipment, materials and technologies that may be used to create missile weapons (MTCR) | RF Government Resolution No. 1288 of 16.07.2022 | Decree No. 1005 of 08.08.2001 |
| 4. Chemical weapons | chemicals, equipment and technologies that may be used to create chemical weapons | RF Government Resolution No. 1284 of 16.07.2022 | Decree No. 1082 of 28.08.2001 |
| 5. Microorganisms and toxins | microorganisms, toxins, equipment and technologies (biological weapons) | RF Government Resolution No. 1287 of 16.07.2022 | Decree No. 1083 of 20.08.2007 |
| 6. Dual-use (armaments) | dual-use goods and technologies that may be used to create armaments and military equipment | RF Government Resolution No. 1299 of 19.07.2022 | Decree No. 1661 of 17.12.2011 |
A separate regulation on the procedure for control applies to each list (regulations on control of foreign economic activity, approved by RF Government resolutions of 2000–2001). The full texts of the lists are available in the legal reference systems ConsultantPlus and Garant.
Competent authorities
| Authority | Function |
|---|---|
| FSTEC of Russia | state policy in export control, issuance of conclusions on whether a good falls within the lists |
| FCS of Russia (customs) | customs control at the border, verification of permissive documents when releasing goods |
| FSMTC of Russia | military-technical cooperation (military products — a related but separate sphere) |
| Expert organisations (CEK) | identification examination of goods (establishing whether a good is subject to control) |
Export-control mechanism
- Identification — the exporter independently determines whether the good falls within the control lists (by name, characteristics, TN VED code);
- Identification examination — where in doubt, the good is referred to an expert organisation (CEK) for a conclusion;
- FSTEC conclusion — on the basis of the examination, the FSTEC issues a conclusion on whether the good belongs to the lists;
- Permissive document — if the good is subject to control, a licence (Ministry of Industry and Trade) or an import/export permit is issued;
- Customs control — the FCS verifies the documents and releases the good.
Dual-use goods
Dual-use goods are goods that may be used for both civil and military purposes or in the creation of WMD. Typical examples: electronic components and computer equipment, machine tools and measuring equipment, chemical substances and materials, software and technologies, and certain types of telecommunications equipment.
The "catch-all" principle (comprehensive control)
Even if a good is not included in the control lists, export control applies where the exporter or the authorities have grounds to believe that the good will be used to create WMD or their means of delivery. In this case the FSTEC may require a permit to be obtained (Article 20 of Federal Law No. 183-FZ).
Liability
| Provision | Offence | Type of liability |
|---|---|---|
| Article 14.20 KoAP | breach of export-control legislation | administrative (fine, confiscation) |
| Article 189 of the Criminal Code | illegal export/transfer of raw materials, materials, equipment and dual-use technologies | criminal |
| Article 226.1 of the Criminal Code | smuggling of dual-use goods and technologies | criminal |